Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York March 5, 1909 (National Park Bank v. West Side Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-03-1909

DAYTON, J.

By the stipulation on the trial the issue was limited to the. indorsement on the check which was the subject of the action. The plaintiff claimed the indorsement of the payee was forged. The defendant alleged that the indorsement of the payee was made by one Wentzel and ratified by the payee. The check was drawn payable to the order of J. E. Manix Co. It was indorsed;

“Pay to the order of J. Hoegerl,

“J. E. Manix Co.,

“J. E. Manix, Pr'es.

"Joe Hoegerl.”

On the trial Manix swore that he was the president of the J. E. Manix Company, that he had not indorsed the check, that neither he nor J. E. Manix Company had ever authorized any one to indorse the check, and that J. E. Manix Company never received the proceeds or any money or property, on account of the check. On cross-examination he was asked if he did not know as a matter of fact that Wentzel wrote the words “Pay to the order of Joseph Hoegerl,” and if Wentzel was in his employ at the time of- the alleged forgery. These questions were excluded. Westervelt, an employé of defendant, testified that he had had conversations with J. E. Manix about this check, and others indorsed by J. E. Manix Company which had gone through defendant’s bank, and that these conversations were had subsequent to the time when plaintiff claimed the check in suit to be a forgery; that he (Westervelt) had never had any conversations with Manix prior to that time. Manix admitted a conversation, and he was asked if during that conversation the subject of the indorsement of the checks drawn to his order was discussed. Manix was also asked if he had stated that he had an employé named Wentzel who had left his employ. He was asked what conversation he had with Westervelt at that time. All these questions were excluded on plaintiff’s exception.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.