Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York November 12, 1909 (Caravia v. Levy)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-11-1909
PER CURIAM.
The plaintiff is a physician, and claims that he and defendant made a contract by which plaintiff was to be paid $20 a week for treating defendant’s wife for tuberculosis of the knee; that he treated her 15 weeks, making a charge of $300, of which only $50 have been paid. Defendant denies any such agreement, but admits plaintiff treated defendant’s wife for tuberculosis of the knee and was paid $50 therefor, and he claims that said payment of $50 was in full *161accord and satisfaction. The issues were submitted to a jury, who found for plaintiff in the full amount claimed. Defendant appeals.
The defendant contends that he and his wife called on plaintiff, who agreed to treat his said wife for $3 a visit when such visit was made at the house of defendant, and $1 a visit when made at plaintiff’s office, and that the visits at these prices called for less than $50, and defendant denies that any weekly arrangement was made. In support of defendant’s claim a check is produced, payable to plaintiff and signed by defendant, for $50, upon which appear the words “paid in full.” This is the check by which the $50 admitted to have been received by plaintiff were paid. There seems, so far as the evidence shows, to be no dispute that these words appeared on the check when delivered, to plaintiff, and that the plaintiff took the check, retained it for several days, and then got the check cashed and kept the proceeds. The cashing of the check, with these words thereon, however, could not be construed as an accord and satisfaction, unless there was a genuine dispute at the time between the parties as to the amount due.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit