District Court, E.D. New York February 23, 1909 (In re Columbia Fireproof Door & Trim Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-02-1909

CHATFIEED, District Judge.

The trustee in bankruptcy has in his possession certain property upon which chattel mortgages were originally given by two men, named Rapaport and Dolgow, on the 24th day of August, 1907. These chattel mortgages were properly filed in the office of the register of Kings county, where the mortgagor Dolgow resided, but were not filed in the county of New York, where the mortgagor Rapaport resided. The statutes of New York provide that a chattel mortgage shall be void against creditors of the mortgagor, unless it is filed according to statute, and further provide that where there are two or more mortgagors, residing in different coun*160ties, the mortgage must be filed in each county where a mortgagor resides.

Shortly after the making of these chattel mortgages; the machines covered thereby were transferred by the mortgagors to a corporation in which the mortgagors were officers, and the title vested in the corporation was taken expressly subject to the rights of the mortgagee. Thus, as between the new corporation and the mortgagee, the debt and the mortgage would be undoubtedly valid, and no question seems to have arisen, up to that point, with reference to any creditor of the original mortgagors. Somewhat later the corporation was thrown into bankruptcy, and the creditors of the corporation now seek to hold these particular machines as free from the mortgage, on the ground that the original filing did not comply with the statute, and that therefore the mortgage is void.

It must be assumed that the creditors of the bankrupt corporation have no greater rights, so far as title is concerned, than the corporation had. They are not in the position of innocent holders for value. The trustee has only succeeded to the title which the bankrupt had, and this title to the machines in question was subject to the claim of the mortgagee.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.