District Court, S.D. Alabama April 22, 1909, No. 1,185 (The Sylfid)

TOULMIN, District Judge.

It is my opinion, on the evidence in this case, that the ship Sylfid is not liable for the damages claimed. Whether the libelant is entitled to recover against the respondent Timothy Dorgan depends upon the question whether said Dorgan was guilty of negligence in the navigation and management of said ship in bringing her from her anchorage in' the river to her berth at