Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit May 19, 1909, Nos. 226, 227 (The Transfer. No. 9)

PER CURIAM.

The District Judge has set forth the facts and the contentions of both sides with great fullness, and they need not be restated here. The case is a very perplexing one, and it is impossible to reconcile the testimony. The District Court had the advantage of hearing all the disinterested witnesses, and also the pilot who navigated the steamer.