U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Pennsylvania February 3, 1909, No. 176 (Wilkins v. Pullman Co.)

HOLLAND, District Judge.

The view which the court took of this case is sufficiently indicated by the following extract from what was said when the nonsuit was granted at the trial of the case:

“The evidence in this case shows no more than that Miss Wilkins, the plaintiff in this case, went to the dressing room, some time in the morning-before daylight, and there she was startled as she opened the