Ohio Circuit Courts January 16, 1909 (St. Aubin v. Toledo)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-01-1909
WILDMAN, J.
This is an error proceeding to reverse a judgment of the court of common pleas rendered in favor of the defendant below, who is the defendant here, upon the sustaining of a general demurrer to plaintiff’s petition. Although the petition in the first instance clearly discloses facts originally constituting a cause of action, it adds allegations which are claimed by defendant to show that the right of the plaintiff is barred by a prior adjudication. The petition does allege the beginning of a former suit, its partial trial, a motion to arrest the case from the jury and says in substance that the court, holding the petition to be insufficient directed a verdict for the defendant. It is not averred that .either a verdict or judgment was rendered. There is in the present case, however, no demurrer on the special ground that the former action’ is still pending and while the petition does not in terms say that the former suit went out of court upon the court’s directing the jury to return a verdict, it is evident that the pleader really intended to charge that. Indeed, counsel on both sides have construed this ■ petition as treating the former action as at an end, as having been disposed of by the direction of the court to the jury to render a verdict. In one of the adjudications of *107the Supreme Court it is stated, in substance, that the rendering of a verdict by the jury after the court has directed one to be rendered is little more than a technical or formal thing. That the submission of a •case to the court on motion to direct a verdict, and the ruling of the court upon that motion, is a decision of the issues to such an extent that it is treated as the final submission to the court, so that a party is not thereafter permitted to dismiss his cause without prejudice. That was held in a case in the Cuyahoga circuit in which I sat with two of the judges of that circuit, Turner v. Car Co. 29 O. C. C. 181 (9 N. S. 65); affirmed, Turner v. Car Co. 79 Ohio St.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit