Ohio Circuit Courts November 17, 1909 (Beckenbach v. Harlow)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-1909

TAGGART, J.

The plaintiff, as tenant of the premises described in the petition, seeks an injunction restraining the defendant from ouster proceedings and declaring a forfeiture of the leasehold. The pleadings and testimony disclose that he has been in the occupation of the premises about ten years; has expended about $12,000 in improvements thereon; that unless this relief is granted he will be subjected to suits in forcible entry and detention; be dispossessed of the property, and will suffer great loss and damage, and that he will be without any adequate remedy at law.

The defendant in his answer admits many of the averments of the petition, and avers the facts to be that the plaintiff has sublet a suite of rooms to a tenant, and has received rent therefor. The defendant further admits that neither Abbie J. Harlow nor Sarah J. Harlow nor the defendant as guardian, have ever actually made any objection to the plaintiff subletting any portion of said premises until February, 1909; that on or about said date defendant notified plaintiff that he was violating the covenants of his lease and elected to forfeit said lease for said underletting, and refused to receive any further rents from plaintiff, and intends to and will insist on such forfeiture, and will adopt and pursue any legal measures to obtain possession of said premises, unless restrained by the courts.

It appears from the evidence that Abbie J. Harlow was the owner *497of these premises from the year 1899 to the year 1902; that she then ■conveyed the same to Sarah Harlow, who thereafter, until the year 1906, managed and looked .after the premises in controversy; that in the year 1906, a guardian was appointed for Sarah Harlow, so that for seven of the ten years during which the plaintiff has been in the occupation of these premises, the owners of the property have had every means of ascertaining how the premises were used and occupied.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.