Supreme Court of the United States February 1, 1909, 61 (Spreckels v. Brown)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-02-1909
Me. Justice Holmes
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an action of ejectment brought by the defendant in error, Brown. He had a verdict and judgment, subject to exceptions. These were taken to the Supreme Coürt of Hawaii by writ of error, the Supreme Court overruled the exceptions and affirmed the judgment below, and the case then was brought to this court. A motion to dismiss was made, on the grounds that the Supreme Court had no authority to enter final judgment, that it does not appear that the property in question is worth five thousand dollars, and that the plaintiffs in error are estopped to say that it has that value by their tax returns, under oath, valuing it at a less amount. This motion can be disposed of in a few words.. For the first ground,
Meheula
v.
Pioneer Mill Co., 17
Hawaii, 91, is relied upon.. See also
Cotton
v.
Hawaii,
211 U. S. 162;
Hutchins
v.
Bierce,
211 U. S. 429. But those cases deal with proceedings upon a bill of exceptions aloneA Here there was, a writ of error, which, as the Supreme Court . of Hawaii pointed out in the decision cited, brings up the judgment. As to the value of the land in dispute,
*210
it sufficiently appears by affidavits in the record and in this court, in which also , there is an attempt to explain the low valuation in the tax returns.
Red River Cattle Co.
v.
Needham,
137 U. S. 632, 635, 636. The tax returns in any event are not conclusive.
Willcox
v.
Consolidated Gas Co., ante,
p. 19. Therefore the motion to dismiss is overruled.
The suit is for two parcels of land, mostly accretions, on the ocean side of Front street,’ Hilo, in Hawaii. The plaintiffs in error are admitted to own the upland on the other side of the street.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit