Supreme Court of the United States February 23, 1909, 91 (Harten v. Löffler)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-02-1909

Mb. Justice'Peckham,

after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the court.

The defendant in error objects that this court is without jurisdiction on the ground of the amount in controversy not being sufficient. Taking the pleadings, the evidence given, and the verdict of the jury,, it would seem that the amount in dispute is sufficient, to give this court jurisdiction. In his set-off the defendant claims the unpaid balance of the purchase price, for the property agreed upon, which unpaid balance amounted to $11,750, and he claims that sum now, and he also claims that the amount of the judgment against him of $1,250 .is erroneous, and that a reversal of this judgment will permit him to claim before a jury on another trial the full amount of his set-off, or at least the balance due for. the purchase price. We think the court has jurisdiction.

Block

v.

Darling,

140 U. S. 234;

Buckstaff v. Russell Co.,

151 U. S. 626.

*404

The objection made by the defendant to the oral evidence goes to its being contradictory to or inconsistent with the written agreement. The. defendant maintains that the. admission of such evidence, was contrary to the rule on that subject. We agree with the Court of Appeals that the evidence was ' properly admitted. The tendency and purpose of the whole evidence were simply to show the circumstances existing at the time when the contract in question was executed, and to identify the premises, and to give point and meaning to the word “about” as contained in the contract.. “About” is a relative and frequently ambiguous term, and its precise meaning is affected by circumstances existing when the word is used in a contract, and known to and recognized by the parties. The evidence was not inconsistent with, nor did it contradict, the written contract, but when a diagram of the premises is shown it plainly appears that the word “about,” with reference to the width of the premises on Brightwood avenue,.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.