Supreme Court of North Carolina September 21, 1910 (Frazell v. Life Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-09-1910

Walker, J.

Tbis action was brought by the plaintiff to recover $192, the amount of premiums paid by him on an insurance policy for $500, which it is alleged be was induced to pay to defendant by false and fraudulent representations of its agent, as to the terms and conditions of the policy. Tbe plaintiff testified substantially that the agent of the company stated to him, before be agreed to take the policy, that it would contain provisions by which the full amount, or $500, would be

*61

paid at Ms death, and if be continued the policy for ten years, the company would pay to' him the amount of all premiums it had received to that time, with interest, upon the surrender of the policy, and if he paid the premium regularly for twenty years, it would become a paid-up policy. There were no such provisions, except the first one, in the policy. Plaintiff paid the premiums for nearly ten years, when he discovered, or was told by the agent of another company, that the policy did not contain the provisions as represented to him. He further testified that he did not believe what the defendant’s agent told him, but sought the advice of his attorney as to the meaning of the contract and believed him and acted on his advice.

At the close of the testimony, the court sustained a motion to nonsuit, and the plaintiff appealed.

If the testimony of the plaintiff is sufficient to sustain the allegation of false and fraudulent representations, within the principles stated by this Court in

Caldwell v. Insurance Co.,

140 N. C., 100;

Sykes v. Insurance Co.,

148 N. C., 18;

Stroud v. Insurance Co.,

148 N. C., 54, and

Whitehurst v. Insurance Co.,

149 N. C., 273, he admitted that he did not believe the agent who made them, and, therefore, he neither relied upon them nor was induced by them to accept the policy and pay the premiums. While he can read and write, and we must assume is a person of ordinary intelligence, he did not read his policy when it was sent to him

(Floars v. Insurance Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.