Washington Supreme Court June 30, 1910, No. 8853 (Case v. San Juan County)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-06-1910
Rudkin, C. J.
The plaintiffs John H. McGraw and George B. Kittinger, copartners under the firm name of McGraw & Kittinger, are the owners of 275 92-100 acres of wild unimproved land in San Juan county, the title to which stands in the individual names of the several plaintiffs, in trust for the copartnership. During the year 1908 the assessor of San Juan county assessed all property in his county at forty per cent of its actual cash value, for the purpose of taxation, and fixed the actual cash value of the property in question at approximately $50,000, or the assessed value at $19,675. The plaintiffs, claiming that this assessment was unreasonable, oppressive, illegal and fraudulent, tendered to the county treasurer the sum of $83.94, in full of all taxes against their property for the year 1908, and upon the refusal of that officer to accept the tender, the present action was instituted to reduce or abate the assessment and to cancel the tax, upon the payment of the amount tendered, and for general relief. The court below adopted and approved the valuation fixed by the county assessor, and dismissed the action. From the judgment of dismissal, this appeal is prosecuted.
The character of the property is such that it is impossible for an assessing officer or a court to fix its actual cash value with any degree of certainty, but we are nevertheless convinced that the valuation fixed by the county assessor and approved by the court below is unreasonable and oppressive, and finds little or no support in the testimony. It is conceded that the lands are wild and unimproved, and are chiefly valuable for the limestone they are supposed to contain. The value of the land, aside from the limestone, does not exceed from $3 to $5 per acre, and the court so found. The testimony tending to show the value of the limestone deposits is extremely meager and unsatisfactory. Only two witnesses *224testified on that 'point, the appellant George B.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit