Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York May 6, 1910 (Brady v. Pennsylvania Steel Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-05-1910
Claeke, .J. :
; This is. the second time that this case has been in this court upon appeal from a judgment in favor of. the plaintiff. In 134 Appellate Division, 372, the judgment was reversed and a new trial ordered ' because the case had been submitted to the jury upon the theory that it was the duty of the master to provide suitable and proper scaffolding for the use of its employees. Weheld that the structure upon which -plaintiff was at work" could not be held to be a scaffold, and reversed the judgment and ordered a new trial.
: Upon thisvtrial the case was submitted- to the jury upon the theory that the master- had failed to -perform his duty to furnish a safe place to the decedent in which to do his worlc. The defendant was engaged in the, construction of the Blackwell’s Island bridge across the East river... The bridge liad two decks. Oil the upper-deck the defendant had installed a traveling derrick called a traveler. The girders ran north and south, and the floor beams east and west, and were bolted fast to the. girders which were permanent. AVooden ties were laid on the, floor beams. . Upon these were laid ordinary *235railroad 'rails spiked down. So that, while the rails remained in. position the ties were securely fastened. On the rails ran the trucks of the heavy traveler which was moved forward from time to time as the progress of the work required. The rails were about forty-five feet long, and as the traveler was moved towards the center of the river, as the work progressed, the rails and ties behind the traveler were taken up and relaid in front of it.
From the center of one of the ties so fastened there had been cut a piece from three to four feet long in order to make an opening through which a guy had been stretched to support a derrick. This opening had existed some eighteen or twenty months prior to the time of the accident.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit