New York Supreme Court September 15, 1910 (Edward Thompson Co. v. Vacheron)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1910

Putnam, J.

This suit arises out of a conditional sale or subscription contract for several legal treatises im the form of an order (dated December 18, 1896) upon plain*84tiff: “Please deliver to me, carriage paid, the complete set of the second edition of the American and English Encyclopaedia of Law, consisting of 32 volumes; and the 4 volume Supplement thereto as issued, for which I agree to pay $7.50 per volume. * * * It is expressly understood that the right of property in all volumes unpaid for shall remain in Edward Thompson Co. until the same are wholly paid for.”

At the foot, was defendant’s signature over his office address in New York, and, in the lower left corner, the words “ Ship to Copake Iron Works, Columbia County, N. Y.” — where defendant resided.

Defendant was to pay instalments quarterly, beginning January 15, 1907; so that one payment came due April fifteenth, which was not paid. Volume 4 of the Supplement was issued in June, 1907, and on the twenty-seventh one copy was given to the American Express Company at Northport (with the freight prepaid) addressed to the defendant, “ Copake Iron Works, N. Y.” It seems, however, that it never reached defendant; and plaintiff’s proof of sending it does not go beyond this evidence of its delivery to the express company. The defendant thereafter demanded this volume, but plaintiff contended that, under the contract, the obligation of delivery had been duly performed.

On January 8, 1909, plaintiff brought suit for the quarterly instalments which had then matured, crediting the defendant with the first payment. The defense is that the contract is entire, and that plaintiff has broken its terms by reason of this non-delivery of volume 4 of the Supplement. On the special issue whether the express company had delivered the book to defendant, the jury’s verdict was in the negative.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.