Supreme Court of Alabama February 10, 1910 (Cox v. Lewis)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-02-1910

MoCLELLAN, J.

— If it is assumed that the bill’s prayer sought relief beyond that possible under a statutory bill to quiet title to real estate (Code, § 5443 et seq.), and that without averring facts sufficient to justify the extended relief prayed, no prejudicial error attended the overruling of the demurrers to the bill (if they took the point indicated), since the court’s decree in the premises conformed strictly, in nature and effect, to a decree responding to a bill drawn within the let*159ter of the statutes cited. It adjudged only that the defendant had no right, title, interest, or claim in or to the lands described in the bill.

The evidence is plenary that the widow and heirs at law of Norris A. Lewis, viz., the complainants, had the peaceable possession of this woodland at the time this bill was filéd, exercising such acts of possession and ownership as it, in its state, permitted; that they claimed to own the land; and that Norris A. Lewis had so claimed to own the land and exercised the like, to those stated, acts indicative of possession and ownership. This state of claim and possession, by Lewis and his successors in right, covered a period of more than 10 years. Otherwise, it was shown that the predecessors in right and title of Lewis had had the possession of the land since 1883. The defendant sought to trace his title and right to the land through a chancery sale, in the enforcement of a vendor’s lien, about 1877, the result of a bill exhibited by Mustin and others against Acker and others. Mrs. Williams and Mrs. Stansei bought at the sale, and latterly they conveyed their respective half interests to E. E. Cox, the defendant. The land in question was described in those proceedings.

There was much evidence leading to the conclusion that the land here involved was erroneously included in the chancery cause mentioned.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.