Supreme Court of Alabama April 21, 1910 (Faircloth-Byrd Mercantile Co. v. Adkinson)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-04-1910
SIMPSON, J.
This suit is by the appellee against the appellant; the first and third being common counts, and the second being on the acceptance of an order.
Defendant demurred to- the second “paragraph” of the complaint, but in its assignments refers to the count, and the court treated it as a demurrer to the second count and overruled it. While this is irregular, yet, as no point was made on the wording of the demurrer, we will treat it as the court did.
The insistence of the appellant is that the demurrer should have been sustained to said second count, because it does not allege that the acceptance of the order was in writing. There was no error in overruling the demurrer. This court has held that, in declaring on the acceptance of a bill of exchange, it is not necessary to allege that it is in writing, although that must be prov-*346fed.—Whilden & Sons v. M. & P. Nat. Bank, 64 Ala. 1, 29, 38 Am. Rep. 1.
Defendant then interposed a plea stating that the said order was not accepted in writing and signed by the defendant, the drawee. A demurrer was interposed to this plea and sustained by the court. In this there was error.
This court has held that an order drawn by one person, upon another, in favor of a third person, for a specific amount, is a “bill of exchange,” and that an acceptance, to be binding, must be in writing and signed as the statute requires. — Anderson & Co. v. Jones, 102 Ala. 537, 538, 539, 14 South. 871; Code 1886, § 1766; Code 1896, § 880.
While the order, itself, and the testimony as to its verbal acceptance, were not admissible in order to fix a.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit