Supreme Court of Minnesota January 28, 1910, Nos. 16,470—(202) (Astell v. McCuish)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-01-1910
Brown, J.
Action in conversion for the value of certain pine logs alleged to< have been unlawfully taken from plaintiff by defendants and converted to their own use. Plaintiff had a verdict in the court below, and defendants appealed from an order denying their alternative motion, for judgment notwithstanding the verdict or for a new trial.
The logs in controversy were “picked up” by plaintiff upon the banks, or as they floated in the St. Croix river above Stillwater. He claims that they were unmarked, and not in the possession or control of any person, and that he took possession of them, marked each with. Lis own mark, and recorded the same with the surveyor general of logs, and lumber of the Stillwater district, after which he rafted the logs and towed them down the river to the city of Stillwater, where they were taken from him by defendants. His title to the logs is founded, upon the provisions of section 2530, R. L. 1905, which provides that *63all logs found in the waters of any lumber district, not in the .possession of or under the control of any person, which have no distinctive mark or marks which have not been recorded in the proper district,, shall be deemed abandoned, and shall not be recognized as property by any court.
The original answer of defendants was a general denial; but on the trial an amendment was allowed, by which they practically admitted having taken the logs from plaintiff, and justified their act as agents-of the St. Croix Boom Company, which, they allege, had the right to the possession of the logs, not only when plaintiff “picked them up,”' but also when defendants seized them at Stillwater. But, aside from this admission and justification, we find evidence in the record to-justify a verdict against all the defendants, unless the rights of the boom company, upon which they rely, are superior to those of plaintiff.
The boom company was chartered by the territorial legislature of 1851. Chapter 9, p. 22, Laws 1851.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit