U.S. Circuit Court for the Southern District of Georgia January 14, 1910 (Henderson v. Phillips)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-01-1910
SPEER, District Judge (orally).
This is a suit for damages for the alleged breach of the following agreement:
“Tifton, Ga., Sept. 17, 1907.
“I, P. A. Henderson, of the county of Miller, of the state of Georgia, party of the first part, do hereby agree to sell and convey unto P. D. & J. J. L. Phillips, of the county of Tift, of the state of Georgia, parties of the second part, for the sum of twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000.00), of which $10.00 is in hand paid and receipt hereby acknowledged, the following property, to wit:
‘•M'y 100 shares of the stock of the Phillips Lumber Company. Fifteen thousand dollars to be paid the 1st of October, 1907, or as soon as property can be examined, which may be a little sooner or a little later, and five thousand dollars six months from the 1st of October, and five thousand dollars twelve months from the 1st day of October, with interest.
“This also cancels an account of three hundred and forty dollars the parties of the second part hold against the party of the first part standing on the Tif-ton books, and one party of the first part holds against the parties of the company on the books at Corea for about two hundred dollars and any other account subject to examination.
“[Signed] P. D. Phillips,
“J. J. L. Phillips.
“P. A. Henderson.
The demurrer is to the effect that this is merely an option, and does not constitute a definite contract; and, further, that the averments of the declaration are not for the recovery of any breach of an option, but for a breach of a definite contract. It would seem thaf'this view of the pleading is correct.
To determine the character of this instrument, to ascertain whether it be merely an option or a definite, agreed upon contract, we must consider the terms of the whole instrument. It is said that it is not a contract, because an examination was provided for; that it was merely an option.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit