Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit May 2, 1910, No. 191 (The Fred Richards)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-05-1910

WARD, Circuit Judge.

February 3, 1907, about 9 :40 p. m., the yawl-rigged yacht Taormina, bound from New York to Newport News, came into collision with a barge towing astern of the tug Fred E. Richards on a hawser 200 fathoms long. The tug and barge belonged to the claimant, and were bound from Philadelphia to Boston. The jibboom and headsails of the yacht were carried away, and she began to leak considerably. Under these circumstances it was perfectly natural that signals of distress should have been displayed on the yacht, as her witnesses testify they were. The witnesses from the tug say that they stood by half an hour (although they did not know there had been a collision until they arrived next morning át White-stone, Long Island), and saw no distress signals. We do not credit *708their testimony ,on this point, and are satisfied that they did not lay by at all, and failed to see the distress signals because of gross negligence, or. willfully disregarded them. . The trial judge held that the. tug’s failure to stand by raised a presumption under the act of September 4, 1890, that.fhe collision was caused by her fault, and we think he was right in so doing. But we arrive at the same conclusion on the testimony.

There is, as usual, great contradiction between the witnesses; but certain significant facts are admitted, viz.: The wind was northwesterly; the yacht was proceeding down the coast upon a course S. by W. W.; the tug and tow were proceeding up the coast on a course of N.N. E.; the vessels were going at about the same speed, and there was but a difference of three-quarters of a point between their courses. The yacht passed the tug close to, port to port, and struck the starboard side of the barge an angling blow, without fouling the towing hawser. As she drew with her fin keel some 12 feet, it is obvious that the towing hawser must have been slack, and that this must have been caused by .the stopping of the tug.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.