Supreme Court of the United States April 25, 1910, 147 (United States v. Welch)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-04-1910

Me. Justice Holmes

delivered the opinion of the court.

This is a. proceeding under the act of March 3, 1887, c. 359, § 2, 24 Stat. 505, to recover the value of land taken by the United States. It is admitted that a strip of about three acres of land lying along the side of Four Mile Creek and running east and west was taken, and is to be paid for. It was permanently flooded by a dam on the Kentucky River, into which Four Mile-Creek flows.

United States

v.

Lynah,

188 U. S. 445.

Manigault

v.

Springs,

199 U. S. 473, 484. The plaintiffs owned other land south of and adjoining the strip taken, and had a private right of way at right angles to the creek northerly across land of other parties to the Ford County Road, which ran parallel to the creek and at some distance from it. This was the only practical outlet from the plaintiffs’ farm to the county road. The taking of the intervening strip of course cut off the use of the way, and the judge who tried the case found that it lessened the value of the farm $1,709. He allowed this sum in addition to $300 for the land taken. The United States took a writ of error on the ground that the former item was merely for collateral damage not amounting to a taking and of a kind that cannot be allowed; that at most it was oñly a.tort. The case is likened to the depreciation in value of a neighboring but distinct tract by reason of the use to. which the Government intends to put that which it takes.

Sharp

v.

United States,

191 U. S. 341, 355.

The petition like the form of the finding lends some countenance to this contention, by laying emphasis on the damage

*339

to the farm, although it is to be noted that even in this aspect the damage is to the tract of which a part is taken.

Sharp

v.

United States,

191 U. S. 354. But both petition and finding in substance show clearly that the way has been permanently cut off. A private right of way is an easement and is land.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.