Supreme Court of the United States May 2, 1910, 493 (Grenada Lumber Co. v. Mississippi)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-05-1910

Mr. Justice Lurton,

after'making the above statement, delivered the opinion of the court.

The agreement and combination which offends against the - Mississippi • anti-trust statute is one between a large majority of the independent and competitive merchants engaged in the retail lumber trade in the territory covered by their ■ articles of association, whereby they have obligated themselves not to deal with any manufacturer or wholesale dealer in lumber, sash or doors, etc., who sells to consumers in localities in which they conduct their business and keep a sufficient stock to meet demands, and to inform each other of any sale made by manufacturers or wholesalers who sell to consumers.

That such an agreement and combination was, within the meaning of the Mississippi statute, a conspiracy “in restraint of trade,” “intended to hinder competition in the production,

*440

importation, manufacture, transportation, sale or purchase of a commodity," is the express decision of the Supreme Court- of. Mississippi, That the object and purpose of the compact was to suppress competition between the plaintiffs in error and another class of dealers in or producers of the same-commodity and the consumer is avowed in the “Declaration of Purpose,” set out heretofore, in which it is stated that the members of the association; as retailers, “cannot meet competition from those from whom they buy.” ■ This concession means,, if it means anything, that those against whom the plaintiffs in error are acting in concert will undér-sell them in the competition for the trade of the consuming public, and must therefore be stopped by concerted refusal to deal with.them if they should persist in such competition. This constitutes under the interpretation of the Mississippi statute by the Mississippi court a “ restraint of trade,” and á hindrance to competitors in the sale of a commodity.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.