Supreme Court of North Carolina October 18, 1911 (Wyatt v. Seaboard Air Line Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-10-1911

AlleN, J.,

after stating the case: The uniform rule, prevailing under our present system, is that the allegations of a pleading shall be liberally construed with a view to substantial justice between the parties, and that every reasonable intendment is made in favor of the pleader.

Brewer v. Wynne,

154 N. C., 472.

The just application of this rule tends to the trial of cases upon their merits, and we would not be justified in relaxing it in a ease like this, where there has been a trial before a jury, and both parties have had full opportunity to present their evidence.

It would require a very strict construction of the allegations of the complaint to give it the meaning contended for by the defendant, to wit, that it only alleges negligence in the operation of the train.

If we give to the pleading every “reasonable intendment in favor of the pleader,” and “construe it liberally,” as our authorities require, the negligent act alleged in the third paragraph of the complaint is that the defendant “negligently and

*313

carelessly permitted said engine to emit sparks and coals of fire therefrom, wbicb fell on plaintiff’s property, etc.”; and the preceding language, “in operating and running an engine,” merely indicates where the engine was, and what was being done with it, at the time of the negligent act.

If so, it was competent for the jury to consider evidence of defects in the engine under the allegations of the complaint.

The defendant’s counsel presented his contention as to the contributory negligence of the plaintiff with much force and ability and cited authority from eminent courts in support of his position.

We do not, however, agree with him that the weight of authority sustains his view, and we think his Honor held correctly that there was no evidence to sustain the plea.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.