Supreme Court of North Carolina May 3, 1911 (McWhirter v. . McWhirter)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-05-1911
Waleer, J.
Tbis action was brought by tbe plaintiff, as administrator of W. C. McWhirter, for tbe purpose of having sold certain land, which is described in tbe complaint and alleged to belong to bis estate, for tbe payment of debts. Tbe defendant, Mrs. R. J. McWhirter, answered tbe complaint and averred that tbe land did not belong to W. C. McWhirter, although be bad tbe legal title thereto, for that be bad bought tbe same with her money and for her benefit, and be therefore held it in trust for her. An issue was submitted to tbe jury, as to tbe existence of tbe alleged trust, express or resulting, and tbe verdict was in favor of Mrs. McWhirter, tbe jury finding that W. 0. McWhir-ter bad purchased the lands with her funds and held tbe legal title in trust for her, having taken a deed for tbe land to himself, instead of to her, as be should have done. Judgment was entered upon the verdict and the plaintiff brings tbe case here by appeal to review tbe rulings of 'the Court, which be deems erroneous.
It is necessary to discuss but a single question, as there is an error in tbe charge of tbe court which entitles tbe plaintiff to another trial. Tbe court at first charged tbe jury correctly that
*147
as the deed to W. 0. McWhirter was absolute in form, and upon its face conveyed' the legal and equitable title to him, the defendant must establish the trust by clear, strong and convincing proof.
Lehew v. Hervett,
138 N. C., 6;
Taylor v. Wahab,
154 N. C., 219;
Cobb v. Edwards,
117 N. C., 253. If the learned judge had stopped there, the charge, in this respect, would have been free from crrpr, but he afterwards told the jury when instructing them again upon the quantum of proof required to establish the trust, that a preponderance of the evidence in favor of it is sufficient.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit