Supreme Court of Colorado April 15, 1911, No. 6442 (Valley Dew Distilling Co. v. Messner)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1911

Mr. Justice Gabbert

delivered the opinion of the court':

*452The defendant in error signed and delivered to plaintiff in error the following order slip:

“Valley Dew Distilling Co.

1 Union Square, New York. Incorporated.

‘ ‘ Gentlemen: I have this day bought of you 10 barrels whiskey in bond, and have received warehouse certificate covering said whiskey as follows: (Then follows description of the articles mentioned).

‘‘ Settlement.

“Cash ...................................$ 21.00

' Notes .................................. 250.00-

“Payable May 20, 1906 ............$250.00

“Which whiskey or its equivalent may be sent upon my order, and the approval of your home office. This order slip, together with said certificate, constitute the complete order, no other agreement being recognized.

“Labels, etc.

“Advertisement, 100 bottles.

“2112-18 Blake St., Denver.

“Remarks: Allowed for 2 bbls.

(Signed) “John Messner.”

The defendant executed and delivered his promissory note for two hundred and fifty dollars and received two' warehouse certificates, each of which (omitting numbers and the specific description of the merchandise therein described) reads the same, as follows:

‘‘ Valley Dew Distilling Company.

“The Valley Dew United.States Bonded Warehouse Distillery, No-. 354, 5th District, located in Louisville, Ky., has received and has on storage the following described five barrels American Sire Club *453"Whiskey, for our account, and which we hold subject to the order of John Messner.” (Then follows a description of the barrels, by numbers, net gallons and other marks intended to identify them.) The receipt then recites: “Deliverable as agreed only on return of this certificate, properly endorsed, and on payment of the purchase price hereof at our main office, and government, state and county taxes and storage, at the rate of five cents per barrel per month from inspection. Loss or damage by the elements, fire, leakage, shrinkage, or transportation at purchaser’s risk.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.