Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit May 8, 1911, No. 194 (Ludvigh v. American Woolen Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-05-1911

lead-opinion

WARD, Circuit Judge.

November 15, 1901, P. Horowitz & Co. entered into a- written contract with the American Woolen Company, to run to December 1, 1902, whereby the Woolen Company agreed to consign goods to Horowitz & Co., the title to the goods or their proceeds to remain in the Woolen Company until fully accounted for, all bills for the consigned goods to be made payable to the Woolen Company, and Horowitz & Co. to receive as their compensation the difference between the invoice and selling prices (which were not to be less than the invoice) and to be allowed a drawing account of $1,200 a month to be deducted from their profits. They were also to give security by way of a lien upon real estate to protect the Woolen Company against loss by reason of any failure on their part to observe the agreement. It was also provided that Horowitz & Co. were not to buy woolens of any one but the Woolen Company. This word, read in connection with the whole agreement, must be understood as meaning to deal with no one else. If it be given the literal construc-*31tiou of purchasing, then the sale to them was not an absolute, but a conditional, sale.

The Woolen Company, apparently because it entertained suspicions of Horowitz & Co., and perhaps, also, because its counsel misunderstood the decision of this court in Re Garcewich, 115 Fed. 87, 53 C. C. A. 510, declined to continue the contract and required that the business should be done thereafter through a corporation. Such a corporation was formed under the name of the Niagara Woolen Company “to contract and deal with the American Woolen Company of New York and to deal in fabrics received therefrom.” November 25, 1902, an agreement was executed between the American Woolen Company and the Niagara Woolen Company whereby the former agreed to consign goods to the latter for one year on substantially the same terms as contained in the agreement of November 15, 1901, with Horowitz & Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.