Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit November 13, 1911, No. 114 (In re American Specialty Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-11-1911
LACOMBE, Circuit Judge.
The referee disallowed the first five items of .the .claim, principally for the reason that the advances in question were made before the American Specialty Company became a corporation. It was difficult to make out from the record what was the date of incorporation, but, upon our suggestion that the record might be sent back to have that date ascertained, the appellee’s counsel conceded that it was some time in 1903, a, time long prior to making of the advances. This disposes of the referee’s first ground of objection.
At the hearing below, there was some question whether or not the Roberta Wilson claim was filed within the year. There was conflicting testimony, and the referee held that it was so filed; a decision which there seems no reason to disturb.
' The referee also held that an assignment from Mrs. Johnson to Mrs. Wilson was proved, and that it was an absolute assignment of the entire claim. The District Judge stated in a memorandum that, if he had had the question to decide on written evidence, he would have found the claim was never lawfully assigned. But he did not reverse the referee; on the contrary, he confirmed his report, which allowed part of the claim. There was evidence tending to show an assignment of the entire’ claim, and we accept the conclusion of the referee on this point.
[1] One item, known as “Exhibit F,” $1,300, the referee disallowed, for the reason that the money was transferred from Mrs. John*809son’s broker to her husband’s broker, and appeared to be a loan to her husband. The evidence shows that she owned some stock, which her broker transferred to another broker, who sold the same and gave the money to Mr. Johnson, who put it in the treasury of the company; a check of the company for $1,300 being drawn to Mrs. Johnson’s order, and delivered to her, which check she never cashed, being asked to wait till the company was in funds.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit