Superior Court of Pennsylvania March 1, 1912, Appeal, No. 73 (Merritt v. Lehigh Valley Railroad)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-03-1912
Opinion by
Morrison, J.,
This was an action of trespass brought to recover the value of two large trunks containing sample merchandise, and the court below submitted the case to the jury and there was a verdict in favor of plaintiff of $509.12. At the trial the defendant asked for a binding instruction, which request was refused, and after verdict the defendant’s counsel moved the court for judgment non obstante veredicto, which was granted, and the plaintiff appealed and in a single assignment of error complains that the court erred in granting such judgment.
The facts developed at the trial, which are undisputed, disclosed that L. E. Hewitt, a traveling salesman employed by the appellants, went to the appellee’s passenger station at Tunkhannock some time before six o’clock in the afternoon of September 2, 1902. He had with him two large trunks which he requested to have checked to Laceyville, exhibiting at the same time a mileage book as the transportation he had purchased. The trunks were found to be overweight and an excess baggage rate of thirty cents was demanded from and paid by Hewitt. The appellee’s baggage master at Tunkhannock was acquainted with Hewitt and knew that he was a traveling salesman, but did not inquire, nor did Hewitt tell him what *222the trunks contained, or by whom the same and their contents were owned. It is now conceded that the trunks contained no personal effects or clothing of Hewitt, but consisted wholly of sample shoes designed for the purpose of effecting sales of similar goods; and that both the trunks and their contents were the exclusive property of the appellants.
The trunks were placed aboard a passenger train leaving Tunkhannock near six o’clock the same afternoon and they arrived safely at Laceyville not later than seven o’clock of the same evening.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit