Supreme Court of Vermont January 20, 1912 (Lyman v. James)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-01-1912

Munson, J.

The suit is for the taking and conversion of an automobile which the plaintiff claimed to own. The defendant justifies under a writ of attachment in favor of one B. B. Perkins. The writ commanded the officer’to attach the property of the “Hill Storage & Implement Co., a corporation organized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of Vermont with its principal office at Burlington.” The defendant attached the automobile as the property of “the within named defendants, the Hill Storage and Implement Co.” Perkins, the plaintiff in this writ, was a creditor of one Wm. H. Hill, who was doing business under the name of the Hill Storage and Implement Company and was the sole person interested therein. The defendant introduced evidence tending to show that the Hill Storage and Implement Company was the same as Wm. H. Hill. There was no evidence and no claim that there was any corporation by that name.

Plaintiff’s counsel, in his closing argument to the jury, claimed that the defendant had no right to attach the automobile on a process issuing against the Hill Storage and Implement Company, a corporation. The plaintiff requested the court to charge that the defendant’s process did not entitle him to take this property even if it belonged to Hill, inasmuch as the writ was against the Hill Storage and Implement Company, a corporation, when in fact no such corporation existed; and excepted to the court’s refusal so to charge. The court, for the purposes of the trial, instructed the jury that the suit was in favor of a creditor of Hill, and that the defendant had a writ regular in form and was bound to make the attachment. „ The plaintiff excepted to this on the ground that the defendant had no process against Hill, and had no right to attach the property of the plaintiff, or even of Hill, on a writ against the Hill Storage and-Implement Company, a corporation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.