Indiana Court of Appeals November 1, 1912, No. 7,711 (Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis Railway Co. v. Clark)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-11-1912

Ibach, J.

This was an action to recover damages from appellants on account of the death of Selma Clark, appellee’s decedent, alleged to have been the result of injuries caused by appellants’ negligence on November 1, 1906.

*6491. *648Cleveland, etc., R. Co. v. Clark (1912), 51 Ind. App. 392, 97 N. E. 822, is a companion case to this, being an action for damages caused by the negligent killing of Maggie Clark in the same accident. The women were sisters-in-law, and were riding in a buggy which was struck by a construction *649train at the crossing of a public highway with appellant railway company’s tracks. Selma Clark was driving. Maggie Clark was very severely crushed about the limbs, and died in a few days. Selma Clark, it is alleged, received injuries which caused her death on April 24, 1908. The complaint in this case, except that it sets out the facts of the occurrence more in detail, is almost an exact copy of the second paragraph of the complaint in the other case. The actionable negligence averred is practically the same. The former complaint was held by this court to be good as against all the defendants. The evidence tending to show that appellant railway company was negligent in maintaining a defective highway crossing, and that appellant Wabash Constructon Company was negligent in the operation of its construction train, and that such negligence on the part of these appellants was the proximate cause of the collision between the train and the buggy, is likewise practically the same as that considered in the former case, and we have nothing to add to what was said in the former opinion concerning this evidence. The sufficiency of the complaint in the present case, and the sufficiency of the evidence in the present case to show negligence on the part of appellants which was the proximate cause of the collision, were conclusively determined against appellants’ contentions by the opinion in the former case.'

2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.