Supreme Court of Puerto Rico April 10, 1912, No. 792 (Torres v. La Sociedad Anónima Tranvía de Mayagüez)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-04-1912

Mr. Justice MacLeary

delivered the opinion of the court.

This action was brought for the recovery of $2,500 damages alleged to have been sustained by reason of personal injuries occasioned by the negligence of the defendant. After the trial in the district court judgment was rendered in favor of the defendant, dismissing the complaint and awarding the costs against the plaintiff. From this judgment an appeal was prosecuted and the case was heard in this court on the 15th of last .month on written briefs filed by the respective parties. In his brief the appellant, who was the plaintiff below, specifies three errors which we will consider in the order in which they are presented:

I. It is alleged that the District Court of Mayagiiez erred in refusing to inspect the pleadings of the parties and to determine, before the evidence was presented, whether or not the allegations of fact contained in the complaint were properly denied in the answer, so as to require proof thereof. It appears from the record that the plaintiff’s attorney, before the introduction of the evidence, presented an oral motion to the court requesting the judge to take the action indicated in the specification of errors, which he declined to do on the ground that the law is clear requiring that all facts- stated in the complaint which had not been denied in the answer are considered as admitted and it is idle to specify what facts *248are not denied by the answer. To this ruling of the court plaintiff duly took exception.

It is true that section 132 of our Code of Civil Procedure provides that every material allegation of the complaint not controverted by the answer must, for the purposes of the action, be taken as true; but we have no statute requiring the trial court to designate, prior to the trial, what facts alleged in the complaint are not controverted by the answer.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.