District Court, N.D. Georgia March 1, 1912, No. 12,413 (United States v. Purvis)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-1912

NEWMAN, District Judge.

This is an indictment under section 213 of the Federal Penal Code of 1910, which provides that:

“No letter, package, postal card, or circular concerning any lottery, gift enterprise, or similar scheme offering prizes dependent in whole or in part upon lot or chance * * * shall be deposited in or carried by the mails of the United States, or be delivered by any post master or letter carrier”— and then fixing a penalty for the violation of the section.

*619'Hiere is a demurrer to tlic indictment upon several grounds.

[1] The first ground 1 will refer to, as it is easily disposed of, is that the charge in the indictment that the defendants “deposited or caused to be deposited in the post office” the letter set out in the indictment is bad for duplicity. This, as I understand it, is not insisted upon; but, even if it should be, this objection to the indictment is clearly not well taken.

[2] The next ground of demurrer which may be considered is that the indictment does not sufficiently charge knowledge on the part of the defendants of the contents of the letter, the basis of the indictment.

The language of the indictment is “did then and there unlawfully and knowingly deposit and cause to be deposited in tlie post office at. Atlanta, Ga.,” etc. The contention is that the word “knowingly” as there used only qualifies the verb “deposit” and not the succeeding language of the indictment setting out the character of the contents of tlic inclosure. In many cases in which it was charged in the indictment that the defendant “did knowingly deposit in the post office” a certain letter, and then proceeds to state “which said letter contained certain unmailable matter,” describing it, it is held that the word “knowingly” not only qualifies the verb “deposit,” but the whole matter described subsequently in the indictment. 13 fine. PL & Pr. 395.

In United States v. Clark (C. C.) 37 Fed. 106, 107, Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.