Supreme Court of the United States February 19, 1912, 145 (New York Continental Jewell Filtration Company v. District of Columbia)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-02-1912

Mr. Justice McKenna

delivered the opinion of the court.

Action of assumpsit by plaintiff in error in the Supreme

*254

Court of the District of Columbia to recqver the sum of $7,172.97 claimed by it as the amount of unexpended balances of three deposits made by it with the District to cover the cost of.certain work.undertaken by the District for it.

. The case was tried to a jury which, under the instructions of the court, returned a verdict .for the plaintiff in thé sum of $1,089.79, with interest, upon which judgment was duly entered. The judgment was affirmed by the Court of Appeals. We shall refer to plaintiff in error as plaintiff and to the defendant in error as the District.

The controversy grows out of work required to be done by certain acts of Congress for the elimination of grade crossings on the line of the Baltimore & Ohio. Railroad Company .in the city of Washington, and requiring the railroad company to depress and elevate its tracks, and to enable it to relocate parts of its railroad therein, and for other purposes. Act of February 12,1901,31 Stat. 767, c.,3'53. The.scheme of improvement was quite extensive anji the act described in detail the changes to Jbe made in the grades of streets in connection with the change of the location of , the railroad company’s tracks and station.

Section 9 of,the act-is1 the one with which we have most concern. It provides as follows, omitting parts not essential to be quoted:

“Sec. 9. That the entire cost and expenses of the revision, changes, relocations, and improvements of and in said railroad, as authorized and required by the preceding sections of this Act, and of all structures connected therewith or incidental thereto, shall be borne, paid, and de-. frayed .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.