Superior Court of Pennsylvania April 21, 1913, Appeal, No. 41 (Wagner's Estate)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-04-1913
Opinion by
Head, J.,
The instrument out of which this controversy arises, if accepted for what it purports to be, satisfies in form at least every requirement of the statute. It is in writing, signed and sealed by the maker and attested by three subscribing witnesses. The maker of this note or bond lived more than twenty years after the date of its execution and delivery. He remained during all of that period actively interested in the church congregation for whose benefit he gave the note. During most, if not all, of the time he himself continued to be one of the officers of that congregation as he was at the time he made the note. This note, according to its terms, became payable one *404year after the death of the maker. The latter died in 1910. When, upon the adjudication of his estate, this note was presented for payment by the congregation for whose benefit it was given, objection to its payment was made by the appellant, one of the general legatees of the testator under his will, on two grounds chiefly:
(a) That it did not appear that the instrument had been executed in the manner prescribed by the act of 1855.
(b) That there was no sufficient evidence of its delivery by the testator in his lifetime.
The learned court below disposed of both questions adversely to the exceptant, and this appeal followed.
1. The evidence leaves no room to doubt that the instrument was signed by the maker, and we have no contention as to that important fact. Of the three persons whose names appear on the note as attesting and subscribing witnesses, two survived the maker and testified before the auditing judge. The third predeceased the maker and the genuineness of his signature was established by due proof. So far as he was concerned, the legal presumption would be, following such proof, that he had placed his signature there in the manner required by the law to make him an attesting witness. Nothing was offered to remove such presumption.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit