Supreme Court of Arkansas October 27, 1913 (Coston v. Lee Wilson & Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-1913

McCulloch, C. J.

Mr. Coston, the appellant, was attorney for the Grassy Lake & Tyronza Drainage District No. 9, of Mississippi County, in the organization of the district, the sale of bonds, and other matters concerning the business thereof, and this case involves a controversy between him and the taxpayers of the district concerning the amount of his fee. Appellees, as taxpayers, intervened in the proceeding before the county court for the allowance of the fee. Appellant claimed^ $20,000, and both sides appealed from an order of the county court fixing the fee at $12,500. The case was tried in the circuit court on appeal, and the fee was fixed at the sum of $8,000.

The judgment of the circuit court was rendered in March, 1912, and some time during the month of May of the same year the commissioners of the district paid to appellant the sum of $8,000,' the amount of the judgment, and took his receipt therefor, which stipulated that he accepted the sum without prejudice to his right to prosecute an appeal.

He prayed an appeal from the clerk of this court on March 28, 1913, just before the expiration of the time, and the appeal was granted.

Appellees now move the court for the dismissal of the appeal on the ground that appellant is estopped by reason of having accepted payment of the judgment.

This question was decided in favor of the contention of appellees in the case of Watkins v. Martin, 24 Ark. 14, where the court, speaking through Mr. Justice Compton, held that, “Where a party has recovered a judgment, and received the amount of it from defendant, he will not be permitted to reverse the judgment on error.”

The only distinction between that case and this is, that, in the former the plaintiff collected the judgment upon process issued at his instance, whereas, in the present case, the payment was voluntarily made by the commissioners of the district.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.