Oregon Supreme Court September 16, 1913 (Thienes v. Francis)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-09-1913

lead-opinion

Mr. Justice Ramsey

delivered the opinion of the court.

This is a motion for a dismissal of the appeal in this suit. The respondent Francis asks that this appeal be dismissed for the alleged reasons that, in the action at law referred to in the above statement of facts, the defendant therein and plaintiff in this suit filed his answer to the amended complaint in said action and voluntarily took part in the trial thereof, after the decree in this suit was rendered, without having first appealed this case, and because, as the defendant alleges, the plaintiff accepted the benefits of said decree and by so doing waived his right to appeal, etc.

The decree appealed from was rendered in the court below on the 11th day of March, 1913, and it enjoined the defendant in this suit from prosecuting said action at law against the plaintiff in this suit and defendant in said action to recover the value of the grain and hay mentioned in the complaint in said action. The defendant herein, and plaintiff in said action, a few days after said decree was rendered, filed his amended complaint in said action and served a copy thereof on the defendant therein. The defendant in said action filed his answer to said amended complaint, and the plaintiff therein filed his reply, and said action at law was tried, and a judgment thereon rendered on April 8, 1913. After the rendition of said judgment, the plaintiff in this suit appealed to this court from the decree rendered as stated.

The defendant herein claims that the defendant in said action, by filing his answer therein and participating in the trial thereof, waived his right to appeal this case. The decree appealed from held that the grain and hay mentioned in the complaint in the action were the property of the plaintiff in this suit and enjoined the defendant therein from prosecuting his said action *175to recover the value thereof, but that was the extent of the injunction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.