Supreme Court of Iowa November 11, 1913 (Nelson v. Western Union Telegraph Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-11-1913

Withrow, J.

This action was brought to recover damages alleged to have been sustained by the plaintiff because of the erroneous transmission of a telegraph message, resulting, as claimed, in a loss by plaintiff of profits in a real estate transaction. There was a trial to a jury, and at the conclusion of the evidence the trial court directed the return of a verdict for the defendant. A motion for new trial was presented and afterwards sustained by the trial court, and the directed verdict was set aside. From the ruling granting a new trial, the defendant appeals.

1. New trial: discretion: review. I. It is agreed by counsel that the ruling of the trial court in passing upon a motion for a new trial is merely a matter of discretion with which the appellate court will not interfere unless it appears that such discretion has been abused. Hunter v. Porter, 124 Iowa, 351. And, although there are instances in which this court may find it proper to set aside such ruling, there is greater reluctance to do so when its effect is to grant a new trial. Tathwell v. Cedar Rapids, 122 Iowa, 50.

It is the claim of the appellant that the ruling of the trial court, as shown by the opinion which is a part of the record, was based upon the single and definite question stated by it whether the evidence showed such a complete acceptance of an offer to sell real estate as to create a contract. Appellant insists that the undisputed testimony upon this question was such that the trial court was bound to hold as a matter of law that there was a completed contract before the sending *52of the telegram which is the basis of this suit, and that therefore no damages were suffered by the plaintiff. It has often been held by this court that, while much latitude is allowed the trial court in the exercise of its discretion, yet such is a legal discretion; and, when the precise ground is stated upon which the court bases its action, we will determine if such discretion has been abused. Stockwell v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.