Supreme Court of Alabama May 15, 1913 (Bell v. Bell)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-05-1913
lead-opinion
MAYFIELD, J.
— The sole bone of contention in this case is, Who are the distributees of the estate of one Jim Bell, deceased, on account of whose wrongful death his administrator had received $1,000 for distribution as provided by the statute? The question was properly raised in the probate court, the evidence was there *648heard ore terms, and the probate judge decided the question in favor of appellants. An application for new trial was made in the probate court by appellees, and a great number of affidavits, in support of and in opposition to the motion, were introduced in evidence. The motion was denied by the probate court, and appellees (here) appealed to the circuit court, as is authorized by section 2855 of the Code. The trial was had in the circuit court on a transcript of the proceedings in the probate court, and the circuit judge, as an appellate court, by virtue of section 2865 of the Code, reversed the judgment of the probate court, and rendered judgment for appellants there (appellees here) ; and from that judgment this appeal is prosecuted to this court, as is authorized by section 2857 of the Code.
The progenitors of these respective statutes were construed by this court in the case of Nooe's Ex’r v. Garner's Adm’r, 70 Ala. 448, which was a proceeding very similar to this, though the question of fact to be determined was different. The rules of evidence as to the weight and sufficiency of evidence to justify an affirmance, a reversal, or a rendition, on the respective appeal, were thus declared by this court:
“Our former decisions have declared three rules, from which we have no wish to depart:
“First. When a contest of fact, properly triable before a jury, is, by consent, submitted to the judge presiding for decision. In this class of cases, this court will not review the finding of the judge on the facts, any more than it would the finding of a jury. It is not assignable as error. — Etheridge v. Malempre, 18 Ala. 565; Barnes v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit