Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit April 21, 1913, No. 3,788 (Chicago Great Western R. v. Hulbert)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-04-1913
HOOK, Circuit Judge.
This was an action by Hulbert, a pedestrian on a public street, for personal injuries resulting from the violent breaking, by some passenger cars negligently managed, of a wire care*250lessly allowed by an electric light company to hang low across the railroad trade. The action was begun in a state court of Iowa against both the railroad company and the electric light company. The plaintiff and the electric light- company were citizens of that state; the railroad company was a citizen of Illinois. The railroad company, claiming there was a separable controversy between it and the plaintiff, removed the cause to the federal court. Plaintiff then moved to remand. The motion was sustained as to the electric light company, but denied as to the railroad company. A trial of the issues between the plaintiff and the railroad company resulted in a verdict and judgment for the former, and this writ of error followed.
[1, 2] It is contended by the railroad company, whom for convenience we will hereafter call the "defendant,” that the trial court lost jurisdiction when it remanded the case as to its codefendant, the electric light company. No exception was taken to the action of the trial court and no objection or complaint was made at any time by either plaintiff or defendant. They proceeded to trial, verdict, and judgment, without a suggestion of want of jurisdiction. Nor does the defendant refer to it in its assignment of errors. The question is raised for the first time in the briefs. It was optional with the plaintiff to sue either or both companies, jointly or severally.; and defendant had no voice in determining his choice. He sued both, and at the instance of the defendant the cause was removed to the federal court on a ground that may be debatable. When it went there the plaintiff could have dismissed it as to the electric light company, leaving the railroad company sole defendant, but instead of doing so he effected the severance in another way.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit