Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit March 22, 1913, No. 1,683 (Stevenson v. Shalcross)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-03-1913
BUFFINGTON, Circuit Judge.
In the court below, Stevenson, the grantee of two patents capable of conjoint use, charged the defendants Shalcross with infringement thereof. On final hearing the court held and decreed the first patent, viz., No. 817,199, granted April 10, 1906, for a door frame, void. Whereupon Stevenson appealed. It also held and decreed claims 4 and 5 of the second patent, No. 812,-377, granted, February 13, 1906, “for improvements in door frames, doors, and adjunctive mechanism for air-tight compartments,” valid and infringed, and that claims 1, 2, 3, and 7 were invalid. Whereupon the Shalcrosses appealed.
[1] Turning to the first patent, we note that it “has for its object the firm bracing of the lower ends of the door jambs and the providing for a substantial threshold to be formed integrally with the concrete floor.” The means suggested for accomplishing this purpose consist of “a door frame having the jambs thereof connected to one another at their lower ends by one or more bars, preferably angle-irons, adapted to be imbedded in and covered by a concrete floor." Stated in simple terms, the disclosure, for which the patentee claims *287a monoply, was the bracing of the lower ends of door jambs by angle-iron. Does this involve patentable novelty, or was it one of those clever expedients which naturally follow the development and needs of the industry to which it pertains? The court below was of opinion the device lacked patentability, and we have reached the same conclusion. Sinking- in the ground a transverse anchor block to keep a fence post in line, and of a ground sill to keep the sides of a gale frame true, are common expedients. Examples thereof may he seen in fence and gate patents. When it was desired to use a brace in concrete, there was no more, patentable novelty in the conjoint use of concrete and steel than there was in other forms of construction work.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit