Supreme Court of Oklahoma November 16, 1915, 5830 (Tulsa Ice Co. v. Wilkes)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1915

Opinion by

BREWER, C.

We are met at the threshold of this case with a motion to dismiss the appeal, which we will first proceed to dispose of. The motion sets up two grounds:

(1) It is urged that the notice to settle was served before the time had expired for suggesting amendments,

*521

and that it did not give the five days’ notice allowed by the court. It was not objectionable to serve the notice while the time for suggesting amendments was running

(Frey v. McCune,

49 Okla. 493, 153 Pac. 109), but the court would be without authority to settle the case-made before the time for suggesting amendments had elapsed

(State ex rel. Davis v. Wheeler et al.,

49 Okla. 357, 152 Pac. 1087); and, had this case been so settled prior to the expiration of the time allowed for suggesting amendments, the point would be well taken. This was not the case, as will appear in discussing the next point.

(2) The second ground is that the notice stated that the case would be presented for settlement on October 13, 1913, and that it shows to have been settled on October 23, 1913, without a showing of the absence or inability of the judge to settle it on the date called for in the notice, or that for any such or other cause the settlement had been postponed. This would likely be fatal also but for the fact that in settling the case the judge certifies:

“The foregoing case-made and the amendments thereto have been duly served in due time, and amendments thereto duly suggested, and the same duly submitted to me for settlement and signing, as required by law, by the parties to said cause; that the same, as above set forth and as corrected by me, is true and correct,” etc.

So this case-made stands as settled after the time allowed for suggesting amendments had passed, but without a sufficient notice of the time and place of its presentation to the judge for settlement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.