District Court, D. Puerto Rico June 16, 1915, No. 897 (Berwind White Coal Mining Co. v. Borinquen Sugar Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-06-1915
HamiltoN, Judge,
delivered tbe following opinion:
Tbe motion is overruled as to tbe last ground. Tbe matter of acreage controlled by corporations bas more tban once been determined by this court to be one for tbe government, and not for individuals to complain of, if at all. Tbe other points require fuller consideration.
1. Tbe Reorganization Committee contends that tbe applicants have no standing iu court, inasmuch as they have opposed reorganization iu all its phases, and cannot now be permitted to claim under tbe reorganization. ■ This does not seem to be well taken. Tbe applicants have been merely exercising their legal rights. They bad tbe right to oppose tbe sales when made. It is true that at that time they could not have set up any claim under tbe sales, but that time is past. Tbe sales have been confirmed aud tbe applicants as nonassenting creditors must, under tbe terms of tbe decree, receive their share of tbe proceeds in cash. They have now become creditors under tbe reorganization instead of opponents of tbe reorganization, and have tbe right to oppose any irregularities which they deem to have been committed or to be imminent in carrying out this plan. Tbe court would have no right to punish them for not assenting to tbe scheme, nor would it have tbe wish to do so if it bad tbe right.
2. These creditors, however, have no more vested right to tbe details of tbe reorganization scheme tban other creditors. It bas seemed expedient to tbe court, in view of all tbe circumstances of tbe case, to allow about six months more to work out *160all tbe details of tbe reorganization. Where there are a number of conflicting interests to be consulted, some at a distance, relating in part to a not only manufacturing, but an agricultural and transportation, business, tbe court is not willing to force tbe large majority in interest to proceed faster than they find practicable.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit