North Dakota Supreme Court April 3, 1915 (Citizens' State Bank v. Christianson)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-04-1915

Goss, J.

Plaintiff seeks to establish title in defendant Christianson, and to foreclose a real estate mortgage given by Christianson and wife for $2,200 and interest. Defendants answered separately. Westby pleads title in himself and denies that C. ever had any interest in the quarter section attempted to be mortgaged by him, and asks that title be quieted against the mortgage sought to be foreclosed. To this plaintiff replies, alleging C. to be the equitable owner of said premises, and that Westby holds the legal title in trust for C. and procured the deed to himself to defraud and defeat the lien of plaintiff’s mortgage. Plaintiff recovered judgment, from which Hans Westby appeals, demanding a trial do novo.

Briefly stated the issues hang upon the following statement of facts: C. came to Pierce county in 1906, where W. was residing. He moved upon W.’s homestead and farmed it that year. W. was working on the railroad as a section hand. Christianson had previously married W.’s sister. W. was unmarried. C. farmed W.’s homestead that year on halves, W. furnishing 600 bushels of oats, giving the use of four horses and machinery, $10.60 in cash, and allowing C. to take all the crop that year, W;’s share amounting to $300, leaving O. indebted to him that fall in the sum of $490.60. Of the foregoing there is no dispute, nor anything upon which to question the good faith of the dealings between W. and C. In the early spring of 1901 a neighbor, defendant Ejeld, desired to sell an adjoining quarter section and the subject of this litigation. He talked with C. about his buying it, and got him interested to the extent that C. made a trip to Bugby and attempted to raise the money or credit sufficient to buy the land, but he failed and could get neither money nor credit for the purpose. During this time and throughout all times involved in this litigation, W. was working on the section in another county and away from his home, except as he would visit it over Sunday.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.