Indiana Supreme Court November 16, 1915, No. 22,800 (Spice v. Astry)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1915

Spencer, C. J.

Appellee, as administratrix of the estate of Jonas Astry, her deceased husband, brought this action to recover damages for his wrongful death. The complaint is in two paragraphs, in each of which it is alleged that on May 18, 1911, appellant and certain of his eodefendants were engaged as independent contractors in the work of installing a refrigerating plant and making certain alterations in a building occupied by the defendant, Swift & Company, in the city of Fort Wayne. The first paragraph of complaint alleges that appellant, a plumbing contractor, installed as a part of said plant a certain pump which he negligently failed to provide with an escape or relief valve for its proper operation, or with proper safety guards; that appellant and his servants, with knowledge of such defects, undertook to operate said pump; that by *3reason of said defective condition and improper installation by appellant, the belt which operated the pnmp was thrown off its pulley and caused to strike certain petcocks in the refrigerating machinery, thus breaking parts of the machinery and permitting the escape of ammonia gas into the basement of the building where appellee’s decedent was at work as a carpenter; that the fumes of the gas caused His death. The second paragraph of complaint does not allege who installed the pump in question but charges that with knowledge of its defective condition and installation, appellant and his codefendants started the pump without taking proper precautions to prevent an accident and thus caused decedent’s death in the manner stated above. '

*41. *3In support of his contention that, under the evidence, the jury improperly returned a verdict against him, appellant relies on the rule that a master is responsible for the acts of his servants only where the latter are acting within the scope of their authority.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.