New Jersey Court of Chancery July 23, 1915 (Hague v. Hague)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-07-1915
Backes, V. C.
This is an undefended action for divorce on the ground of desertion. The master, to whom it was referred, advised a decree, and his.report came before me for approval during last summer’s vacation of Advisory Master Biddle, who has charge of undefended divorce cases. The report was not approved because the petitioner’s testimony failed to show willful, continued and obstinate desertion; her evidence was uncorroborated, and also if she intended to rely upon a constructive desertion, the justifying facts and circumstances of her leaving should have been pleaded. Smithkin v. Smithkim,, 62 N. J. Eq. 161. At the request of counsel, the cause was re-referred to the master for further proof. The only witness called was the husband, whose testimony did not aid the petitioner’s cause, and a divorce was denied' and a decree of dismissal entered. From this decree an appeal has been taken, and I have been requested to give my reasons for denying the petitioner relief.
*676The petition alleges that the parties were married November 20th, 1909, and that in the month of December, 1911, the defendant deserted the petitioner, and that the desertion was willful, continued and obstinate for two years next before the commencement of the suit, February 27th, 1914. These facts may be gathered from the petitioner’s testimony: After the marriage the couple lived with the petitioner’s parents in Glen Ridge for three months. They then kept house on Washington street, in the same town; from there they went to Caldwell Cedars; thence to “The Sign of the Hammer,” a hotel on Bloomfield avenue, Montclair, where they lived in December, 1910, when the petitioner left the defendant and returned to her father’s home, where she has ever since stayed. Her husband wrote her a letter asking her to return and make up with him, which she did not answer, and after a few days he left the apartment and went to his mother’s home.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit