Hamilton Circuit Court March 29, 1915 (Cincinnati Trac. Co. v. Harrison)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-03-1915
GORMAN, J.
This was an action to recover damages for personal injuries sustained by the defendant in error, by reason of a collision between her automobile and a ear of the plaintiff in error company, on Gilbert avenue, near Chapel street, in January, 1912. A verdict of $3,750 was rendered in her favor below, and the cause is now here on error.
The principal contention of plaintiff in error is that the verdict is against the weight of the evidence. We have read the record of the evidence in the case, and carefully considered same. It appears that defendant in error was driving out of the premises of Mrs. Krippendorf, on the west side of Gilbert avenue, about forty feet south of Chapel street. There was a slight cut in the driveway near the street line, and the driveway gradually sloped from the house, which stood back perhaps eighty or a hundred feet, to the street line. Plaintiff in error claims that it was such negligence on the part of the chauffeur, who was driving the automobile of defendant in error, to drive his automobile onto the street car track ahead of a north bound car on *437Gilbert avenue; that the defendant in error is precluded from recovery.
The evidence tends to show that at the time the chauffeur drove out upon the street, there was a south bound ear standing at the intersection of Chapel street and Gilbert avenue, about forty feet north of the driveway, the front end of the south bound car being not more than ten or fifteen feet from the driveway. There was a great deal of snow, which had been cast onto the sides of the street by the sweepers of the traction company, leaving no space between the street car tracks and the curbs on either side of Gilbert avenue for the automobiles or vehicles to pass, and it was necessary for automobiles to keep to the center of the street along the street car tracks in order to pass over the street.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit