Supreme Court of the United States November 29, 1915, 386 (Heim v. McCall)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-11-1915

After stating the case as above,

Mr. Justice McKenna

delivered the opinion of the court.

There seems to have been no question raised as to the right of Heim to maintain the suit, although he is not one of the contractors nor a laborer of the excluded nationality or citizenship. The Appellate Division felt that there might be objection to the right, under the holding of a

*187

cited case. The Court of Appeals, however, made no comment, and we must — certainly may — assume that Heim had a right of suit; and, so assuming, we pass to the merits.

The Supreme Court put its decision upon the power of the State “to provide what laborers shall be employed upon public works” and that “the State has the same right in conducting its business that an.individual has” and had, therefore, “a perfect right to enact § 14 of the Labor Law, and it does not violate any rights of an alien under existing treaties.”

The Appellate Division of the court, however, was of opinion that the law could not be sustained upon such' consideration and saw in it such flagrant discrimination as to be offensive to the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States; and so concluding, the court considered it unnecessary to discuss the effect of treaties.

The court also passed, without absolute decision, the question whether the Labor Law applies to the work of building subways for the Rapid Transit in the City of New York. It was, however, stated in the opinion of the court that in view of the language in a cited case, there was “much ground for saying that even if the State could lawfully impose the test of citizenship upon employés of its own contractors, and the contractors with the city engaged in what is properly state work, it has no more power to impose such test upon the persons employed in building a subway for the city than it would have if the subway were being constructed by a private corporation or individual.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.