California Supreme Court August 2, 1916, Sac. No. 2261. (Vore v. Ephraim)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-08-1916

*247

SHAW, J.

The defendants have appealed from the judgment. The court below made an order that plaintiff’s motion to dismiss defendants’ motion for a new trial be granted. The defendants filed two notices of appeal from this order, one designating it as an order denying defendants’ motion for a new trial, and the other designating it as an order dismissing defendants’ motion for a new trial.

The appeal from the judgment was taken within sixty days after its entry. A bill of exceptions for use on the motion for new trial was duly proposed and settled and is set forth in the transcript. A bill of exceptions so settled for use on motion for new trial may be used in support of an appeal from the judgment, although it was not regularly used on the motion for a new trial.

(Wall

v.

Mines,

128 Cal. 138, [60 Pac. 682];

Vinson

v.

Los Angeles etc. Co.,

141 Cal. 154, [74 Pac. 757];

Gay

v.

Gay,

146 Cal. 240, [79 Pac. 885]; Code Civ. Proc., sec. 950.) As the appeal from the judgment was taken within sixty days, the sufficiency of the evidence may be considered, as well as the alleged errors of law occurring at the trial. (Code Civ. Proc., sec. 939;

Brown

v.

Towles,

7 Cal. 398;

Walls

v.

Preston,

25 Cal. 59;

Harper

v.

Minor,

27 Cal. 107;

Haviland

v.

Southern C. E. Co.,

172 Cal. 601, [158 Pac. 328].) From these principles it appears that the questions presented may be as well reviewed on appeal from the judgment as upon an appeal from an order denying a motion for new trial. Hence the elaborate discussions in the briefs regarding the action of the court below upon the motion for new trial, and its effect upon our authority to review the errors of law presented, are unimportant and require no consideration at our hands.

The complaint stated a cause of action to quiet the plaintiff’s alleged title to about twenty acres of land included within the boundaries of the east half of section 3, township 13, range 9 east, in Placer County.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.