Supreme Court of North Carolina October 18, 1916 (Mills v. Atlantic Coast Line Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-10-1916

*267

HoKe, J.

Eailroad companies, in the exercise of their franchise as common carriers of passengers, are held to- a high degree of care in looking after the safety of passengers upon their trains. In furtherance of this obligation their conductors and station agents are constituted, by the State statutes, special policemen to enable them the better to perform their duty, and the company is responsible for assaults and actionable wrongs committed upon them by other passengers or third persons which could have been 'pnmdecl against or prevented by the utmost vigilance and foresight.

Stanley v. R. R.,

160 N. C., 323;

Carpenter v. R. R.,

124 N. Y., 53;

Kuhlen v. R. R.,

193 Mass., 341;

Spohn v. R. R.,

82 Mo. App., 74.

"While this is the standard of care imposed in such cases, it is also well recognized here and elsewhere that these companies are not insurers of the safety of passengers and are not liable for injuries which, in the exercise of such care, their conductors, employees, agents, etc., could not have reasonably foreseen and prevented.

Pruett v. R. R.,

164 N. C., 3;

Ry. Co. v. Hinds,

53 Pa. St., 512; 2 Hutchison on Carriers (3 Ed.), sec. 981.

In application of these principles, and on careful consideration of the facts presented in the record, the Court is of opinion that the plaintiff has shown no right to recover in this ease and that defendant’s motion for nonsuit should have been allowed. From these facts it appears that in August, 1916, plaintiff, a passenger on defendant’s train, from "Wilmington to New Bern, was assaulted by another passenger, one George "Wooten, and, according to plaintiff’s version, received painful injuries.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.