Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court May 19, 1916 (Hurter v. Larrabee)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-05-1916

Rugg, C. J.

This is a bill for an accounting by two retiring members of a partnership against three remaining general partners, who hereafter will be referred to as the defendants. The firm carried on a wholesale dry goods business of considerable magnitude. The articles of copartnership provided, among other matters, that upon the termination of the partnership two or more of the general partners having a majority interest therein might continue the business under the firm name, and in that event should “ pay to the retiring general partners, for their interest in said business, the amount standing to the credit of each of the retiring general partners on the books of the firm January 1, 1913, after the stock taking of that date, and after the interest and profit has been placed to each general partner’s credit.” The three defendants elected to continue the business, and the two plaintiffs, to retire. Disagreement as to how much should be paid to the plaintiffs caused this suit. The case was referred to a master under a rule which required him "to state the accounts in accordance with the terms of the partnership.” Exceptions to the master’s report present the questions to be decided.* There has been no bad faith on the part of any of the partners.

*220The plaintiffs’ first exception is to the refusal of the master to make a finding upon the negligence of the defendant Brady in supervising the accounting department of the firm. The duties of the several partners were not defined by the partnership articles, but by common consent Brady, in addition to having charge of a special department, exercised a general oversight of the conduct of the business and of the office and bookkeeping and accounting department. But the bookkeeping was in charge of one Ferguson until just before the dissolution of the partnership, when he left. Ferguson was generally trusted by all the parties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.