Supreme Court of Colorado December 4, 1916, No. 8753 (Vreeland v. Murray)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-12-1916
Opinion by
Mr. Justice Teller.
The plaintiff in error was plaintiff below, in an action on promissory notes.
The first defense pleaded is want of consideration, it being alleged that the defendant gave the notes for a balance due on the purchase price of an automobile which she bought of plaintiff on the representation that it was a new machine, whereas in fact it was a secondhand machine, such fact not being known to defendant when she executed the notes; that the value of the machine was not more than $2500, while the purchase price was $3500.
There were three other defenses by way of counter claims pleaded, claiming damages; one because of the taking by plaintiff of the automobile from the garage where it was stored; one because of - the use of it by plaintiff, without consent of the defendant; and the other because of the appropriation and use by the plaintiff of various parts of said machine.
*323The replication set up an accounting on which a balance was found due to the plaintiff, to evidence which said notes were given.
The court found in favor of the defendant and judgment was entered accordingly.
It appears that the car was purchased on July 24, 1909, at the agreed price of $3,000, but nothing paid thereon at the time;' July 27, 1910, plaintiff rendered to defendant a bill which included the purchase price of the car, with additions bought for it, and repairs and supplies; a total of $3,585. Defendant then conveyed to plaintiff an equity in some real estate which was taken at a valuation of $2,850. Plaintiff at that time loaned defendant $700, leaving a balance due him of $1,435. This balance was evidenced by promissory notes. The notes not having been paid, the defendant gave to the plaintiff, on December 7, 1911, a chattel mortgage on the car to secure the notes. In April, 1912, plaintiff, learning that the- car was about to be sold under a judgment against the defendant, for garage charges, took possession of it and removed it to another garage.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit